💡 OnlyFans vs Zivity: Why Creators Are Asking “Which One’s Better?”
If you’re a creator trying to make a buck online, you’ve probably heard the buzz: OnlyFans is the big dog in town, but Zivity’s been quietly carving out its own niche. And now, with Tim Stokely—the OG founder of OnlyFans—back on the scene launching a new platform called Subs, the plot thickens even more.
So, what’s the deal? Why are creators scratching their heads over whether to stick with OnlyFans or jump ship to Zivity? And how does this new kid Subs fit in?
Well, the answer boils down to growth, monetization, and how easy it is to actually build an audience without the usual headache of hustling on X or Reddit. OnlyFans, despite its explosive pandemic-fueled growth, has been criticized for being a bit of a black box when it comes to organic discovery. Meanwhile, Zivity leans into its community vibe and artist-friendly features, appealing to those wanting a more “curated” experience.
In this article, we’ll break down what makes these platforms tick, compare their features, and chat about what the future might hold for creators in Canada and beyond. Whether you’re a new creator wondering where to invest your time or a fan curious about where your fave stars hang out, I’ve got you covered.
📊 OnlyFans vs Zivity: Feature & Monetization Breakdown
| Feature 🛠️ | OnlyFans 💰 | Zivity 🎨 | Subs (Upcoming) 🚀 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Subscription Model | Monthly paid subscriptions, pay-per-view | Subscription & pay-per-view, community tipping | Mixed safe-for-work & adult, subscriptions + private calls |
| Audience Building Tools | Limited internal discovery, relies on external traffic | Community-driven, better internal engagement | Instagram-style explore feed, shows feature |
| Content Restrictions | Adult content allowed, strict policies | Adult content mostly, artistic focus | Mixed NSFW and SFW content under one roof |
| Revenue Streams | Subscriptions, tips, pay-per-view, messaging | Subscriptions, tipping, community support | Subscriptions, private messages, one-on-one calls |
| Creator Support | Basic tools, creator payouts ~80% | Community support, more creator control | Enhanced discovery, ad-free user experience |
| Popularity & Reach | Global leader, millions of users | Niche audience, smaller but loyal | New player, aiming to combine best of both worlds |
This table lays it all out: OnlyFans is still the heavyweight champ in terms of sheer global reach and revenue power. Creators love the multiple revenue streams, but many gripe about the challenge of growing organically inside the platform itself—it’s like you gotta hustle outside the app to drive fans in.
Zivity, on the other hand, feels more like a tight-knit community where creators and fans vibe better internally. It’s less about mass appeal and more about niche, artistic adult content, plus features like community tipping that feel more “real” and supportive.
Then there’s Subs, Tim Stokely’s new project, which is shaping up to be a hybrid playground for creators. It promises slick discovery with an Instagram-style explore feed and YouTube-like shows, aimed at making it way easier for creators to build and monetize audiences without relying heavily on outside traffic.
💡 What Creators Are Saying & What’s Next?
Here’s the scoop from content creators I’ve chatted with across Canada and beyond: OnlyFans is the go-to for serious money-making, but it’s a grind. Some feel burnt out trying to funnel followers from Twitter (now X) or Reddit to their OnlyFans profile. Plus, recent controversies and content bans have made a few creators wary, especially after stories like Bonnie Blue’s permanent ban despite warnings [The Tab, 2025].
Zivity is getting props for giving a more “creator-friendly” environment, especially for those who want to mix artistic expression with adult content. Its smaller scale means the audience is tight but loyal, which can be great for sustainable earnings and less drama.
Now, Subs is turning heads because it’s led by Tim Stokely—the guy who built the original OnlyFans empire. Early buzz points to Subs being more creator-centric with tools designed to boost discoverability inside the platform. The addition of one-on-one calls as a revenue stream is a fresh take, potentially letting creators cash in on premium, personalized content. This kinda feature is a game-changer, especially when platforms like Cameo charge a premium for such interactions.
Creators often mention how the pandemic flipped the subscription content game on its head, revealing huge demand for adult and safe-for-work content alike. Subs’ approach to house both under one roof with a sleek, ad-free experience could seriously shake up the market.
Lastly, it’s worth noting how pop culture keeps nudging these platforms into the mainstream. Earlier this month, fashion icon Rick Owens opened an OnlyFans account just for his feet [Yahoo, 2025], highlighting how diverse creator content has become. Meanwhile, stories of celebrities like Jessie Cave from Harry Potter turning to OnlyFans to pay off debts show just how vital these platforms have become for many.
🙋 Frequently Asked Questions
❓ What makes Subs different from OnlyFans and Zivity?
💬 Subs is designed by OnlyFans’ original founder, Tim Stokely, to combine the best of adult and safe-for-work content under one platform. It features Instagram-like discovery and YouTube-style shows, making it easier for creators to build and monetize audiences without depending on external traffic.
🛠️ Can I grow my audience solely on Zivity without promoting elsewhere?
💬 Zivity has a more community-driven setup, which helps with internal engagement, but like most platforms, promoting your content outside is still recommended to maximize reach.
🧠 Is OnlyFans still the best platform for making serious money?
💬 OnlyFans remains the market leader with vast user numbers and multiple revenue options, but the competition is heating up. New platforms like Subs aim to offer improved discovery and monetization tools that might level the playing field soon.
🧩 Final Thoughts…
The subscription content game is evolving fast. OnlyFans still dominates, but cracks are showing—especially around audience growth challenges and content restrictions. Zivity offers a niche, community-focused alternative, while Subs, with its fresh features and backing by OnlyFans’ founder, could shake things up by blending discovery with diverse content styles.
If you’re a creator in Canada or anywhere, it pays to keep an eye on all three. Your choice might depend on your content style, how much you want to hustle for traffic, and what kind of audience you want to build.
📚 Further Reading
Here are 3 recent articles that give more context to this topic — all selected from verified sources. Feel free to explore 👇
🔸 Rick Owens is Opening an OnlyFans Account for His Feet
🗞️ Source: Yahoo Entertainment – 📅 June 2025
🔗 Read Article
🔸 Inside OnlyFans University, where the next generation of Bonnie Blues do ‘gay for pay’ lessons
🗞️ Source: The Tab – 📅 June 2025
🔗 Read Article
🔸 Harry Potter star reveals ‘desperate’ OnlyFans videos including pouring strawberry milk in her hair to pay off £8k debt
🗞️ Source: The Sun – 📅 June 2025
🔗 Read Article
😅 A Quick Shameless Plug (Hope You Don’t Mind)
If you’re creating on OnlyFans, Fansly, or similar platforms — don’t let your content go unnoticed.
🔥 Join Top10Fans — the global ranking hub built to spotlight creators like YOU.
✅ Ranked by region & category
✅ Trusted by fans in 100+ countries
🎁 Limited-Time Offer: Get 1 month of FREE homepage promotion when you join now!
🔽 Join Now 🔽
📌 Disclaimer
This post blends publicly available information with a touch of AI assistance. It’s meant for sharing and discussion purposes only — not all details are officially verified. Please take it with a grain of salt and double-check when needed.